This paper attempts to go deeper into foundational issues of contemporary ethics and economics such as: the departure of XX century mainstream economics from Adam Smith’s broad view of human nature, where empathy plays a crucial role, to embrace the unpleasant, greedy homo economicus, the philosophical underpinnings of which can be traced back to Machiavelli and Hobbes (via Bentham); the (unnecessary) link between self-interest and rationality such that rational self-interested humans may turn out to be social idiots; the contrast between homo oeconomicus, homo cooperans and homo moralis; the negative effects of the generational egoism that underlies the economistic (neoliberal) approach to climate change and to the assessment of policies aimed at facing global warming; the difficult coexistence of markets and incentives with goods that should not have a price. In the past hundred years or so many economists went a long way to firmly separate their discipline (which mainly deals with markets and incentives) from ethics. However, Markets need morals, which cannot be made by markets.
Boitani, A., Individualismo, egoismo, eticaed economia, <<Nuova Rivista di Teologia Morale>>, 2024; 1 (1): 32-66 [https://hdl.handle.net/10807/288936]
Individualismo, egoismo, etica ed economia
Boitani, Andrea
Primo
2024
Abstract
This paper attempts to go deeper into foundational issues of contemporary ethics and economics such as: the departure of XX century mainstream economics from Adam Smith’s broad view of human nature, where empathy plays a crucial role, to embrace the unpleasant, greedy homo economicus, the philosophical underpinnings of which can be traced back to Machiavelli and Hobbes (via Bentham); the (unnecessary) link between self-interest and rationality such that rational self-interested humans may turn out to be social idiots; the contrast between homo oeconomicus, homo cooperans and homo moralis; the negative effects of the generational egoism that underlies the economistic (neoliberal) approach to climate change and to the assessment of policies aimed at facing global warming; the difficult coexistence of markets and incentives with goods that should not have a price. In the past hundred years or so many economists went a long way to firmly separate their discipline (which mainly deals with markets and incentives) from ethics. However, Markets need morals, which cannot be made by markets.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.