Recent logic and linguistic literature suggest that certain forms of denial cannot be reduced to a simple assertion of negation. In particular, the existence of mathematical and empirical conjectures offers a basis for refuting Frege’s thesis of equivalence between denial and assertion of negation. Following this line of thought we develop a formal framework with two primitive illocutionary operators for assertion and denial, where denial is not as negation of assertion. We introduce a semantics for the operators mentioned above. Finally, we discuss the relations between asserted and denied contents.
Carrara, M., Chiffi, D., De Florio, C., Towards a polarized semantics for assertion and denial, <<LOGIC JOURNAL OF THE IGPL>>, 2024; (N/A): 1-12. [doi:10.1093/jigpal/jzae090] [https://hdl.handle.net/10807/284403]
Towards a polarized semantics for assertion and denial
De Florio, Ciro
2024
Abstract
Recent logic and linguistic literature suggest that certain forms of denial cannot be reduced to a simple assertion of negation. In particular, the existence of mathematical and empirical conjectures offers a basis for refuting Frege’s thesis of equivalence between denial and assertion of negation. Following this line of thought we develop a formal framework with two primitive illocutionary operators for assertion and denial, where denial is not as negation of assertion. We introduce a semantics for the operators mentioned above. Finally, we discuss the relations between asserted and denied contents.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.